EIT-tuomari on saanut valehdella kelpoisuutensa?

Laura Ervo, dosentti, Helsingin yliopisto,Anne Nikula, varatuomari, Helsinki

Asko Välimaa, OTL, lainsäädäntöneuvos
Oikeusministeriö
Helsinki

Arto Kosonen, OTL, VT, valt.kand,
Ulkoasiainministeriö

Johanna Niemi-Kiesiläinen, oikeustieteen professori
Umeå universitetet

.. ”valintapaneelin” päätöksistä ei ole saatu asiakirjakopioita, ellei niitä myöhemmin jostain putkahda?

Moitittavaa tässä valintapaneeli-touhussa on, kun virkavallan korkeimmalla huipulla harrastetaan lapsellista salaseuramaista koplailua.

TOISTAISEKSI, valintapaneelin toiminnasta on vain tämä näyttö ja lausuma:

—– Forwarded message —-

From: pauliine.koskelo@om.fi
Date: Sat Oct 14 12:57:36 EEST 2006
To: ”Esko Kärkäs” <tirapisu@luukku.com>
Subject: Vs: Asiakirjapyyntö

Pyyntönne johdosta totean, että Euroopan ihmisoikeustuomioistuimen jäsenet valitsee Euroopan Neuvoston parlamentaarinen yleiskokous asianomaisen jäsenvaltion asettamista ehdokkaista (Euroopan ihmisoikeussopimuksen 22 artikla). Suomessa ehdokasasettelun valmistelu kuuluu ulkoasiainministeriölle, joka on asiaa valmisteltaessa kuullut eräitä oikeushallinnon ja oikeuslaitoksen edustajia. Tarkoittamaanne kutsuasiakirjaa ei ole, vaan pyyntö on tullut ulkoasiainministeriöstä puhelimitse.

Totean myös, että vastoin käsitystänne Euroopan ihmisoikeustuomioistuin ei ole kansallisiin ylimpiin tuomioistuimiin nähden seuraava oikeusaste.

Euroopan ihmisoikeustuomioistuimen tehtävistä ja toiminnasta on saatavissa tietoa esimerkiksi tuomioistuimen internet-sivuilta.

Pauliine Koskelo
—– End forwarded message —–

VUOSI 1984: 85 päivää

VUOSI 1985: 57 päivää

VUOSI 1990: 4 kuukautta (Orimattila)

VUOSI 1994: 3 kuukautta (Lahti)

VUOSI 1995: 1 vuosi (Lahti)

Yhteensä alle 2 vuotta ja 2 kuukautta.

Näissä lukemissa ollaan hyvin kaukana Päivi Hirvelän englanninkielisessä Curriculum Vitaessa ITSE ilmoittamastaan 9 vuodesta.
Vaikka kuinka keskustellaan siitä mikä olisi oikea englanninkielinen käännös kuvaamaan Päivi Hirvelän tekemisiä Kouvolan hovioikeudessa; tosiasia on, että ilmoittaessaan olleensa tuomarina 9 vuotta, Hirvelä ei ole puhunut totta.

District Prosecutor, Lahti Prosecutor’s Office (1 September 1990 – 31 January 1999)

Assistant Judge of the Court of Appeal, Kouvola Court of Appeal (1 August 1982 – 31 August 1990)

Referendary, Office of the Parliamentary Ombudsman (14 September 1998 – 31 January 1999, ancillary job)

District Judge, Lahti District Court (1 October 1994 – 31 December 1995, on leave from the District Prosecutor’s Office)

District Judge, Orimattila District Court (1 February – 31 May 1990, on leave from the Court of Appeal)

District Prosecutor, Lahti Prosecutor’s Office (1 January 1986 – 4 April 1988, on leave from the Court of Appeal)

District Judge, Lahti District Court (1982 – 1986 many periods, ancillary job)

Legal Aid Counsel in Lahti (1 June – 31 August 1982)

Legal Aid Counsel in Sodankylä (12 November 1981 – 28 February 1982)

Rural Police Chief, Kolari Police District (22 May – 21 June 1980)

b. Non-judicial legal activities

Assistant in Criminal and Procedural Law, University of Helsinki, Faculty of Law

(1 July 1996 – 31 March 1997, on leave from the District Prosecutor’s Office)

Researcher, University of Helsinki (1 January – 30 June 1996, on leave from the District Prosecutor’s Office)

Research Assistant, The National Research Institute of Legal Policy (28 August – 21 November 1980)

Activities and experience in the field of human rights

Public office

Member of a working group set up by the Ministry of Social Affairs and Health tasked with regulations concerning the Mental Health Act: those concerning criminal patients in the Penal Code (2005 – 2006).

Board member of the National Research Institute of Legal Policy 2004 –

Member of a working group set up by the Ministry of Justice tasked, based on international obligations, with preparing penal provisions in respect of trafficking in human beings, the sexual abuse of children, child pornography and illegal immigration (2002 – 2003).

Member of an expert working group set up by the Ministry of Social Affairs and Health to develop the practice to uncover offences against children (2001 – 2003). Member of a working group set up by the Ministry of Justice tasked with assessing the use of video hearings in courts of law in the case of intimidated witnesses (2003).
Doc. 10942 3.

Member of a working group that focused on the arrangement of prosecutors’ basic training (2000 –2001).

Member of the crime prevention committee set up by the Ministry of Justice (1999 –2002).

Member of a working group tasked with the revision of the legislation on the execution of sentences to social service and the tasks of Probation Services (1998 – 1999).

Teaching work in the field of criminal procedure for prosecutors and other government organisations.
Publications

A book ISBN 951-670-003-9: A Child in Criminal Proceedings

An article, the Journal of the Finnish Lawyers’ Association, vol. 95, 1997 number 7: A Child in Criminal Proceedings – Evidence Problems in Incest Cases

Currently in the process of writing my doctoral thesis with the title: Criminal Process in Sexual Crimes against Children. The Actualization of The Human and Basic Rights of a Child’s Integrity in a Legal Process”. Opponents assigned for doctoral thesis on 23 February 2006.

I confirm that I will take up permanent residence in Strasbourg if elected a judge on the Court.

Helsinki 21.2.2006

(Signed)
Päivi Hirvelä

Tuntuu oudolta: Julkisessa keskustelussa ministereiltä vaaditaan rehellisyyttä mm. tv-lupamaksuissa; sitä vastoin EIO:n ihmisoikeustuomarin virkaan voidaan nimittää filungista epäilty oikeusoppinut.

Toisaalta, EU-Suomen hallinto- ja lainkäytön moraali on muutoinkin epämääräisessä laatutasossa.
Kalevi Kannus

Ref.; The election on 27th of June 2006 of MS Päivi Hirvelä to become a judge at the European Court of Human Rights.
You told me having been a secretary of the Election Panel. Were You actually a referendary of this Panel? Are You a lawyer yourself? Who was the chairperson of the Election Panel?

So far I Have not received the answers to all my questions nor copies of the documents I have requested. Pls urge them.
The Recommendation 1649 (2004)1 for Candidates for the European Court of Human Rights states as follows

2. In order for the European Court of Human Rights to continue to inspire confidence, it is vital that the process by which judges are selected and appointed also inspire confidence.
MS Camilla Busck-Nielsen do You think that above corresponds the way the three Finnish candidates were chosen?

3. The Parliamentary Assembly insists that the process of appointment must reflect the principles of democratic procedure, the rule of law, non-discrimination, accountability and transparency.
MS Camilla Busck-Nielsen do You think that process of appointment reflects above?

17. The Assembly notes that the Committee of Ministers has been reluctant to comment on the decision-making process in member states for the nomination of candidates; recalling that the national procedures for selecting candidates are not always satisfactory, it urges member states to publish their procedures for the selection of candidates for the Court.

MS Camilla Busck-Nielsen has Finland published her procedures for the selection of candidates for Court as per above? If yes, may I have a Copy.

20. The Assembly also urges the governments of member states to notify their parliaments and their appropriate committees of their procedures and timetables when drawing up lists of candidates for the Court.

MS Camilla Busck-Nielsen has the Finnish government notified her parliament and the appropriate committees of the procedures and timetables when drawing up lists of candidates for the Court as per above? If yes, may I have the copies sof those documents. If not, why not?

MS Päivi Hirvelä has written in her CV, that she has been State Prosecutor since 1. Feb 1999. Presently she is on leave from the Office of the Prosecutor General. There is no mentioning of the leave and the reason of it, why not?

She has written in her CV that she has been 9 years a Judge and 16 years a Prosecutor . That makes total of 25 years. She has started her carrier as a Judge so she claims 1 August 1982 in the Court of Appeal in Kouvola. This would mean 1982 plus 25 years the year 2007. The application has been written on 21 Feb 2006 and present year is still 2006 so somehow this does not match. From the other document it is known that she has been on maternity leave in 1988 and 1989 over 12 months . So she has not been able to have been a judge and a prosecutor for 25 years or how do you explain this?

By the way are You also totally sure that she has been a real Judge appointed by the President of the Republic of Finland ie hovioikeudenneuvos as they are called in Finnish in the court of Appeal in Kouvola from 1 August 1982 till 31 August 1990 or has she been so called viskaali in Finnish or referendary only?

I am waiting Your answers.
Yours faithfully
Jali Raita, diploma engineer
Email jraita@mac.com

Copy
Parliamentary Assemby
Council of Europe
Avenue de l’Europe
67075 Strasbourg Cedex
Tel. +33 (0)3 88 41 20 00
Fax: +33/ 388 41 27 81
Mikko Elo, MP, Chief of Finnish delegation to the Council of Europe

VUOSI 1984: 85 päivää

VUOSI 1985: 57 päivää

VUOSI 1990: 4 kuukautta (Orimattila)

VUOSI 1994: 3 kuukautta (Lahti)

VUOSI 1995: 1 vuosi (Lahti)

Yhteensä alle 2 vuotta ja 2 kuukautta.

Näissä lukemissa ollaan hyvin kaukana Päivi Hirvelän englanninkielisessä Curriculum Vitaessa ITSE ilmoittamastaan 9 vuodesta.
Vaikka kuinka keskustellaan siitä mikä olisi oikea englanninkielinen käännös kuvaamaan Päivi Hirvelän tekemisiä Kouvolan hovioikeudessa; tosiasia on, että ilmoittaessaan olleensa tuomarina 9 vuotta, Hirvelä ei ole puhunut totta.

District Prosecutor, Lahti Prosecutor’s Office (1 September 1990 – 31 January 1999)

Assistant Judge of the Court of Appeal, Kouvola Court of Appeal (1 August 1982 – 31 August 1990)

Referendary, Office of the Parliamentary Ombudsman (14 September 1998 – 31 January 1999, ancillary job)

District Judge, Lahti District Court (1 October 1994 – 31 December 1995, on leave from the District Prosecutor’s Office)

District Judge, Orimattila District Court (1 February – 31 May 1990, on leave from the Court of Appeal)

District Prosecutor, Lahti Prosecutor’s Office (1 January 1986 – 4 April 1988, on leave from the Court of Appeal)

District Judge, Lahti District Court (1982 – 1986 many periods, ancillary job)

Legal Aid Counsel in Lahti (1 June – 31 August 1982)

Legal Aid Counsel in Sodankylä (12 November 1981 – 28 February 1982)

Rural Police Chief, Kolari Police District (22 May – 21 June 1980)

b. Non-judicial legal activities

Assistant in Criminal and Procedural Law, University of Helsinki, Faculty of Law

(1 July 1996 – 31 March 1997, on leave from the District Prosecutor’s Office)

Researcher, University of Helsinki (1 January – 30 June 1996, on leave from the District Prosecutor’s Office)

Research Assistant, The National Research Institute of Legal Policy (28 August – 21 November 1980)

Activities and experience in the field of human rights

Public office

Member of a working group set up by the Ministry of Social Affairs and Health tasked with regulations concerning the Mental Health Act: those concerning criminal patients in the Penal Code (2005 – 2006).

Board member of the National Research Institute of Legal Policy 2004 –

Member of a working group set up by the Ministry of Justice tasked, based on international obligations, with preparing penal provisions in respect of trafficking in human beings, the sexual abuse of children, child pornography and illegal immigration (2002 – 2003).

Member of an expert working group set up by the Ministry of Social Affairs and Health to develop the practice to uncover offences against children (2001 – 2003). Member of a working group set up by the Ministry of Justice tasked with assessing the use of video hearings in courts of law in the case of intimidated witnesses (2003).
Doc. 10942 3.

Member of a working group that focused on the arrangement of prosecutors’ basic training (2000 –2001).

Member of the crime prevention committee set up by the Ministry of Justice (1999 –2002).

Member of a working group tasked with the revision of the legislation on the execution of sentences to social service and the tasks of Probation Services (1998 – 1999).

Teaching work in the field of criminal procedure for prosecutors and other government organisations.
Publications

A book ISBN 951-670-003-9: A Child in Criminal Proceedings

An article, the Journal of the Finnish Lawyers’ Association, vol. 95, 1997 number 7: A Child in Criminal Proceedings – Evidence Problems in Incest Cases

Currently in the process of writing my doctoral thesis with the title: Criminal Process in Sexual Crimes against Children. The Actualization of The Human and Basic Rights of a Child’s Integrity in a Legal Process”. Opponents assigned for doctoral thesis on 23 February 2006.

I confirm that I will take up permanent residence in Strasbourg if elected a judge on the Court.

Helsinki 21.2.2006

(Signed)
Päivi Hirvelä

Tuntuu oudolta: Julkisessa keskustelussa ministereiltä vaaditaan rehellisyyttä mm. tv-lupamaksuissa; sitä vastoin EIO:n ihmisoikeustuomarin virkaan voidaan nimittää filungista epäilty oikeusoppinut.

Toisaalta, EU-Suomen hallinto- ja lainkäytön moraali on muutoinkin epämääräisessä laatutasossa.
Kalevi Kannus

Ref.; The election on 27th of June 2006 of MS Päivi Hirvelä to become a judge at the European Court of Human Rights.
You told me having been a secretary of the Election Panel. Were You actually a referendary of this Panel? Are You a lawyer yourself? Who was the chairperson of the Election Panel?

So far I Have not received the answers to all my questions nor copies of the documents I have requested. Pls urge them.
The Recommendation 1649 (2004)1 for Candidates for the European Court of Human Rights states as follows

2. In order for the European Court of Human Rights to continue to inspire confidence, it is vital that the process by which judges are selected and appointed also inspire confidence.
MS Camilla Busck-Nielsen do You think that above corresponds the way the three Finnish candidates were chosen?

3. The Parliamentary Assembly insists that the process of appointment must reflect the principles of democratic procedure, the rule of law, non-discrimination, accountability and transparency.
MS Camilla Busck-Nielsen do You think that process of appointment reflects above?

17. The Assembly notes that the Committee of Ministers has been reluctant to comment on the decision-making process in member states for the nomination of candidates; recalling that the national procedures for selecting candidates are not always satisfactory, it urges member states to publish their procedures for the selection of candidates for the Court.

MS Camilla Busck-Nielsen has Finland published her procedures for the selection of candidates for Court as per above? If yes, may I have a Copy.

20. The Assembly also urges the governments of member states to notify their parliaments and their appropriate committees of their procedures and timetables when drawing up lists of candidates for the Court.

MS Camilla Busck-Nielsen has the Finnish government notified her parliament and the appropriate committees of the procedures and timetables when drawing up lists of candidates for the Court as per above? If yes, may I have the copies sof those documents. If not, why not?

MS Päivi Hirvelä has written in her CV, that she has been State Prosecutor since 1. Feb 1999. Presently she is on leave from the Office of the Prosecutor General. There is no mentioning of the leave and the reason of it, why not?

She has written in her CV that she has been 9 years a Judge and 16 years a Prosecutor . That makes total of 25 years. She has started her carrier as a Judge so she claims 1 August 1982 in the Court of Appeal in Kouvola. This would mean 1982 plus 25 years the year 2007. The application has been written on 21 Feb 2006 and present year is still 2006 so somehow this does not match. From the other document it is known that she has been on maternity leave in 1988 and 1989 over 12 months . So she has not been able to have been a judge and a prosecutor for 25 years or how do you explain this?

By the way are You also totally sure that she has been a real Judge appointed by the President of the Republic of Finland ie hovioikeudenneuvos as they are called in Finnish in the court of Appeal in Kouvola from 1 August 1982 till 31 August 1990 or has she been so called viskaali in Finnish or referendary only?

I am waiting Your answers.
Yours faithfully
Jali Raita, diploma engineer
Email jraita@mac.com

Copy
Parliamentary Assemby
Council of Europe
Avenue de l’Europe
67075 Strasbourg Cedex
Tel. +33 (0)3 88 41 20 00
Fax: +33/ 388 41 27 81
Mikko Elo, MP, Chief of Finnish delegation to the Council of Europe